This guide walks you through how to buy rental property with a mortgage, from choosing a strategy to closing, and ends with a worked cash-to-close and cash-flow example you can adapt to your own deal. Before you start, gather two years of tax returns, recent pay stubs or bank statements, and a rough tally of your savings and monthly debts. I’m Duane Buziak, a licensed mortgage broker in Virginia, Florida, Tennessee, and Georgia. I shop hundreds of wholesale lenders for each client, so you aren’t limited to one company’s rate sheet.
By Duane Buziak, NMLS #1110647
Step 1: Pick Your Investment Strategy and Loan Path
Decide what you’re buying before you talk rates, because occupancy (whether you’ll live in the property or not) drives the loan program and the price of the loan. The main options:
- Single-family rental: you won’t live there, so it’s underwritten as an investment property.
- 2-4 unit property you’ll live in (house hacking): you occupy one unit and rent the others. This can open owner-occupant programs with lower down payments.
- Longer-term portfolio: several properties over time, where how each loan is structured affects your ability to qualify for the next.
Up Lending by Duane Buziak is operated by a licensed mortgage broker (NMLS #1110647, Coast2Coast Mortgage LLC NMLS #376205), not a single-shelf direct mortgage company. A broker places your loan with whichever wholesale lender fits your file best, which gives you more leverage than one company’s menu.
The main loan paths for rentals:
- Conventional investment loan: full documentation of income, credit, and assets.
- DSCR loan: a debt service coverage ratio loan qualifies you mainly on the property’s rent rather than your personal income.
- FHA or VA for house hacking: these require you to live in the property. HUD’s FHA Section 203(b) page covers one-to-four-unit owner-occupied eligibility, and VA.gov explains VA home loans. Neither works for a pure rental you won’t occupy.
- Bank statement or other non-QM loans: “non-QM” means the loan falls outside standard qualified-mortgage documentation, which helps self-employed buyers whose tax returns understate cash flow.
- Foreign National loans: for non-U.S. buyers without a U.S. credit history.
Step 2: Check Your Credit, Income, and Reserves Against Investor Rules
Investment loans are underwritten more strictly than primary-home loans: higher minimum credit scores, larger down payments, and required reserves, meaning liquid cash left after closing, usually counted in months of the property payment. Fannie Mae’s rules sit in the Selling Guide, including B2-1.2-01 on occupancy types. As of 2026, conventional investor loans commonly need 15% to 25% down depending on unit count. Check that page for current maximum loan-to-value ratios, because they change.
Next, estimate your debt-to-income ratio (DTI): total monthly debts divided by gross monthly income. Rental income often doesn’t count in full. Fannie Mae’s rental income rules generally use a market rent figure from the appraiser’s rent schedule (Form 1007 for a single-family home) and count a reduced share of it, commonly 75%, against the property’s payment. Confirm the current treatment for your program.
For example, suppose you earn $8,000 a month, pay $1,800 in housing, and carry $400 in other debts. A property with $2,700 in market rent and a $2,087 payment would count $2,025 of rent (75%), leaving a $62 shortfall added to your debts. Your DTI would be ($1,800 + $400 + $62) ÷ $8,000, or about 28%.
To see where you stand before any score impact, ask for a soft credit pull mortgage review. My NoTouch Credit Pull is a credit review that uses a soft inquiry, so it doesn’t register as a hard inquiry on your report, and it lets us do no hard inquiry mortgage pre approval planning first.
Common mistake: opening a new credit card or financing furniture before closing. New accounts change your score and DTI, and underwriters recheck both before funding.
Step 3: Budget the Down Payment, Closing Costs, and Reserves
List every cash need up front:
- Down payment
- Closing costs (origination, title, recording, prepaid taxes and insurance)
- Appraisal and inspection fees
- Reserves, commonly several months of the full payment (principal, interest, taxes, insurance, called PITI, plus HOA dues for PITIA) per property
Closing costs don’t disappear on investment purchases. Seller credits can reduce what you bring, but the limits are lower than for a primary home. As of 2026, Fannie Mae has generally capped interested-party contributions at 2% for investment properties; confirm that in the Selling Guide.
Where the cash can come from
Savings are the cleanest source. Gift funds are generally not allowed for investment property purchases under Fannie Mae rules, so don’t plan on a family gift the way a primary-home buyer might. A HELOC on your own home can fund a down payment, but the new HELOC payment goes into your DTI, and the funds must be documented. I can structure this alongside your purchase loan.
Pricing
Investment loans typically price higher than owner-occupied loans, and the price moves with down payment and credit score. Ask for quotes at several down payment levels, say 15%, 20%, and 25%, and compare the payment against the cash you’d tie up. For market context, check the weekly Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, which tracks owner-occupied averages, then expect investor pricing to sit above it. I can’t promise any specific rate, so treat every number as a quote request, not a given.
Step 4: Run the Numbers on a Specific Property (Worked Example)
This is an illustration, not a quote. Suppose you’re buying a $300,000 single-family rental with 20% down, and the 30-year fixed rate is an assumed 7.25%.
- Down payment: $300,000 × 20% = $60,000. Loan amount: $240,000.
- Principal and interest: about $1,637 per month at the assumed rate.
- Property taxes ($3,600 a year): $300. Insurance ($1,800 a year): $150. No HOA.
- PITI: $1,637 + $300 + $150 = $2,087 per month.
Cash flow and cash-on-cash return
Use a conservative rent, here $2,700. Subtract a 5% vacancy allowance ($135), 5% for maintenance ($135), and 8% for property management ($216), which totals $486. Monthly cash flow: $2,700 − $2,087 − $486 = $127, or $1,524 a year.
Cash invested: $60,000 down, plus an assumed $9,000 in closing costs (3%), plus six months of PITI in reserves ($12,522), for $81,522. Cash-on-cash return is annual net cash flow divided by total cash invested: $1,524 ÷ $81,522 = about 1.9%. That’s thin, and it’s the kind of result you want to see before you make an offer, not after.
The DSCR check
DSCR is monthly rent divided by monthly PITIA. At $2,700 rent against $2,087, the ratio is about 1.29. A 1.0 ratio means rent exactly covers the payment ($2,087 in rent). A 1.25 ratio needs about $2,609. Higher ratios generally mean easier approval and better pricing, and some programs accept ratios below 1.0 with adjustments. Thresholds vary by program, so I check them against the specific wholesale options for your deal.
Step 5: Compare Loan Options and Get Preapproved
The structural difference between a broker and a direct mortgage company shows up in how you shop. Competitor details below reflect how these companies are generally structured; their program menus change, so confirm current offerings with each directly.
| Factor | Up Lending by Duane Buziak (broker) | Rocket Mortgage / Movement Mortgage (direct) |
|---|---|---|
| Access to loan sources | Hundreds of wholesale lenders, compared for your file | One company’s own rate sheet and products |
| Loan program breadth | Conventional, DSCR, bank statement, Foreign National, FHA/VA for owner-occupied multi-unit | Broad consumer menus; investor-specific options vary, so confirm directly |
| DSCR and non-QM | Available through wholesale partners | Not assumed here; ask each company |
| Credit pull timing | Soft pull review first via NoTouch Credit Pull; full pull when you choose a property and program | Typically a full application and hard pull for a firm quote |
| How rate shopping works | One conversation, many sources compared | Quote by quote, company by company |
| Where they’re strong | Matching unusual files to the right program; Scotsman Guide #114 ranked originator, VA Broker of the Year 2024-2025 | Brand recognition, polished digital tools, one company handling the process |
Start with a mortgage pre approval without hard pull: a soft-inquiry review where I look at your credit, income, and assets and map them to programs. Move to a full credit pull only once you’ve picked a property and a program.
Then request a preapproval letter written for investment property occupancy. Sellers’ agents read it differently than a primary-home letter, and a letter that matches your actual plan avoids surprises when underwriting begins.
Step 6: Make the Offer, Close, and Set Up the Rental
In your offer, include financing and appraisal contingencies. On tenant-occupied properties, ask for existing leases and the rent roll, and order an inspection. The appraiser may need to produce a rent schedule, so don’t be surprised by the extra form.
During underwriting, answer document requests the same day. Keep funds seasoned in your account and avoid large unexplained deposits, which underwriters will ask you to document. Under federal rules you should receive your Closing Disclosure at least three business days before closing; the CFPB explains the Closing Disclosure and its timing. Compare it line by line against your Loan Estimate.
After closing, three things to handle:
- Entity decisions: talk to an attorney and a CPA about whether an LLC makes sense. This isn’t legal or tax advice. Transferring title to an LLC after closing can trigger the loan’s due-on-sale clause, so talk to me first.
- Landlord insurance: a standard homeowner policy often doesn’t cover a rental. Get a landlord policy in place by closing day.
- Reserve account: keep your reserves in a separate account for repairs and vacancies so the property’s rent isn’t your only cushion.
Your Next Move: A No-Credit-Hit Review Before You Pick a Property
The best next step is a no credit hit mortgage application review with me at 804-212-8663. We’ll sort out which loan path fits your strategy and how much cash the deal will really take, before you spend on appraisals or tie up a contract.
Ready to experience a fast, simple, and stress-free path to homeownership or refinancing? Connect with our trusted mortgage experts today and discover the right loan solution tailored to your unique financial situation, whether you’re a first-time buyer, seasoned investor, or anywhere in between.
